Which seventh episode is your favorite?
1.07 Hook Man
0(0.0%)
2.07 The Usual Suspects
6(33.3%)
3.07 Fresh Blood
1(5.6%)
4.07 It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
0(0.0%)
5.07 The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
0(0.0%)
6.07 Family Matters
0(0.0%)
7.07 The Mentalists
5(27.8%)
8.07 A Little Slice of Kevin
0(0.0%)
9.07 Bad Boys
4(22.2%)
10.07 Girls, Girls, Girls
0(0.0%)
11.07 Plush
2(11.1%)
12.07 Rock Never Dies
0(0.0%)
13.07 War of the Worlds
0(0.0%)
14.07 Unhuman Nature
0(0.0%)
"The Usual Suspects" is a classic for a reason--great cinematography, an interesting twist on the usual case structure, and some fun little character moments--and "Plush" is a nice late-season throwback, with some fabulously creepy visuals and no clear answers about culpability, but if we're using the metric of "how many times have you watched it", the far-and-away winner is "The Mentalists". It's just an all-around enjoyable episode, with a good balance of monster-of-the-week and interplay between the brothers, and one of the most memorable lines from the entire show: "You are a virile manifestation of the divine."
