Prologue: All Is Not Lost - In October 1958, Henry Winchester and Josie Sands investigated a haunting in Beardstown, Illinois, and everything went smoothly. A few weeks later, they prepare for their initiation.
Chapter 1: This New World - In October 2005, Sam Winchester's made a big-city life for himself with his girlfriend in Boston, Massachusetts. The night before Halloween, the life he'd left behind in Lebanon, Kansas breaks into his apartment, in need of a shave and help tracking down their father.