If you were going to introduce someone to Supernatural, which 5 episodes would you use to do so? A lot of episodes from seasons 4 and 5 wouldn't work, because they're so arc-heavy. Most of 7 has a completely different feel from the rest of the show, and all the flashbacks in beginning of 8 might be confusing. Hollywood Babylon would probably work pretty well, as would Night Shifter or Folsom Prison Blues, or ... well, most of 2 would work pretty well. And 1, and a fair chunk of 3. Parts of 6 would be okay, and the two halves of 10, barring opening, closing, and center episodes. Haven't watched enough of 9 to be able to judge.
Okay, off the top of my head, and in order by season:
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
...Argh. I can't do it. Maybe two lists? One for if they feel more like funny stuff, another for creepy?
Funny: Tall Tales ... No, that's no good either. I look at the list of episodes and get paralyzed because I just want to do them all, but if you could share only 5....